Anime Food Fact or Fiction: Tempura + Snow Cone = Food Poisoning?

Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 06 copyIt’s time for round 2 of Anime Food Fact or Fiction!

Last time we dealt with the mysterious “poisonous potato”, and today, in honor of the increasing temperatures of the approaching summer in the northern hemisphere, we’ll be looking at something that frequently pops up in anime: food poisoning….

Let’s set the scene: In episode 13 of K-On (season 2), Azusa dreams of visiting the Hirasawa household with an ice cold watermelon as a house gift. Ui serves it up for her sister Yui, who is too busy studying and playing her guitar to come down and greet Azusa. After Ui brings the watermelon up to her sister, Azusa asks her what they had for lunch, to which Ui responds that they ate tempura! With a look of horrified realization on their faces, they race to the stairs to warn Yui not to eat the watermelon, lest she get food poisoning!

But, it’s all a dream, and Azusa wakes up with a start….

Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 03Then, at the end of the same episode, Yui returns home from the summer festival where she ate a snow cone. She sees a plate of tempura on the dinner table and decides to eat it… Just as she’s chowing down, she gets a call from Azusa who asks her if she received the postcard she sent. Yui finds it, and reads Azusa’s warning not to eat tempura together with snow cones…

But, it’s too late! And, this time, it’s not a dream… Yui doesn’t feel so well!

So, is it true? Eating snow cones or watermelon and tempura causes food poisoning?

The answer would have to be… False! (sorta…)

Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 02I wasn’t able to find any conclusive evidence that eating these foods together or in succession causes food poisoning, per se…. After all, food poisoning is an illness that results from consuming contaminated food (such as by a virus, parasite, bacteria, or toxin), and wouldn’t generally be present in properly prepared foods.

If we assume that Yui ate properly prepared foods, and that the food she ate was not spoiled in any way, then what could have caused her sickness? Where did this food myth originate from?

Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 04From what I was able to find (and, admittedly, it wasn’t too much), I have determined that the “food poisoning” is simply a case of an upset stomach! Eating greasy foods (such as tempura) in excess is never a good thing to do, and many sources say that it can cause indigestion all on its own. Adding in extremely cold foods (such as snow cones) could exasperate the indigestion, and cause an upset stomach.

Another reason behind this anime food myth could be the philosophy behind the classification of Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 01foods into pairs that should not be eaten together, according to traditionalEastern medicine. These pairs may have something to do with yin/yang theory, or even the classification of foods into “hot” and “cold” categories, as per traditional Chinese medicine. Coincidentally, among these pairs are watermelon and tempura, and unagi (eel) and umeboshi (picked plum), both of which are listed on Azusa’s postcard as food combinations for Yui to avoid.

So, should you eat snow cones and tempura together? Well, you won’t get food poisoning, but you could get an upset stomach/indigestion… I think it really depends on the person and how sensitive their stomach is!

For more information about tempura and snow cones causing food poisoning/upset stomach/indigestion:

Anime Fact or Fiction - Food Poisoning - K-on 13 - 07

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Anime Food Fact or Fiction: Tempura + Snow Cone = Food Poisoning?

  1. I looked up in Japanese whether it’s true that you shouldn’t eat tempura and watermelon together. All the websites I saw said exactly the same thing: YES IT’S TRUE (supposedly). They actually give a reason: tempura contains a lot of fat, which is hard to digest in the first place. Watermelon is mostly water, which will dilute your stomach acid, making digestion even more difficult.

    So basically any fatty food + any watery food is supposed to be bad.

    However this seems to be BS, as there’s no evidence that water will somehow hamper digestion**. Moreover they say you shouldn’t eat watermelon, but don’t say anything about actually *drinking water* while eating tempura.

    **Sorry it’s a reddit post, but the most sourced reference I could find is this: https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/frz3r/gastroenterologists_does_drinking_water_or_any/c1i7otb

    Most English speaking websites I saw actually said that water helps digestion. But they don’t site sources, so I guess there’s no reason to trust them more than all the Japanese websites that say the opposite…

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s